How to Effectively Make Decisions as a Team

I don’t know about you, but I love to watch people.

When I lived in California and visited San Francisco, some of the most fun of the day was walking through the city and just observing all of the unique and eccentric people or people groups. The human statue. The man playing his nose as a flute. The guy declaring the apocalypse was upon us..again. And all free. What a country we live in!

As humans, we are all so alike yet all so very different.

Do you also find it interesting to watch the leadership styles of individuals and how they get things done?


I do.

And regardless of the type of leader, whether business, teacher, pastor, or leader-wanna-be, leaders can move people or projects from one position or phase to another, but how they do it is the great determiner between pushing and following.

Two leadership extremes

I have seen two styles of leadership extremes that are both harmful: 1) those who get things done by forging ahead, surprising people, clueless of who they have left in their wake, and 2) those who get things done, painfully, over much time, as they have to get consensus from everyone before moving the ship forward. There are usually good motives behind getting everyone on board, but progress is slow and in the end there are still those who disagree.

Unfortunately, I have had past ordeals where I have dabbled in too much of both. And they are painful to think about because the motive behind then is less than pure. Either I want my agenda to happen or I fall into people-pleasing and want to be sure everyone is “OK.”

I have had some memorable experiences in my prior academic life as a VP of Academics. I desire to be a people-oriented leader and take into consideration the opinions and voices of others. But yet as the visionary there are times when the “trigger just has to get pulled.”

I can think of situations where I made a decision without considering all those who might be impacted, and then one of my people confronted me on it…and I had nothing to say in defense. I just took “trust money” out of their bank.

I can also think of situations where I have so desired to get everyone in agreement on a decision that I fell into analysis-paralysis and the wheel of progress began to grind…to…a…halt. And after all of the time I spent, people were disillusioned that we had not made any movement forward.

“Well pardon me, but I was just trying to make sure you all were in agreement with our direction!”

Neither extreme is effective.

What is leading by consensus?

In today’s post I want to spend a bit of time on the latter of the two – leading by consensus. Oft times we think about leading by consensus like making decisions means the leader has to spend an exuberant amount of time convincing and cajoling. And that things are at a standstill until everyone supports the initiative.

I read an interesting quote by Eric Schmidt, the executive chairman of Alphabet Inc. As Schmidt comments, we fail to understand what consensus means. As I read his words, what I saw were two types of people who emerge: those who are convincers and those who are visionaries and executors.

It’s not about everyone agreeing, it’s about everyone being heard and then rallying around the best answer.

Think about it for a moment. If I am not the one making a decision, what really builds trust for me is when my up-line asks for my opinion because he or she wants to make a best decision. In general, people just want to be heard. Especially if they are impacted in any way by the outcome. Expect outspoken criticism and complaining when decisions are made without people being heard.

A fault of mine in the past has been thinking my role is to exert energy in getting everyone to come to my side.

That is not it at all.

I communicate. I listen. I then make a best decision. That is what effective leaders do.

Schmidt also says this:

When it comes to communication, default to openMaximize the velocity and volume of information flow.

In other words, get information out ahead of the curve so that your people are not surprised. No one likes being the last to know. And get as much information out as you possibly can. Treat those you lead like you want want your family to treat you.

That means both giving and receiving information.

If you want to erode trust as a leader, let your people, students, teammates find out information after the decision was made and exclude those who have a vested interest and want to follow you.

Consensus is not 100% agreement

But if you want to lead by consensus, and do it with effectiveness, realize that you do not have to have 100% agreement before a decision can be made. The competent shepherd sees a decision that needs to be made, gathers his people around, lays out the vision, asks for feedback and listens, and then makes a decision that is in the best interest of all who have a stake in the direction being set.

As I have chosen to operate with this definition of consensus, I have seen the appreciation and gratefulness of those around me who have been intentionally brought into the picture. They may not necessarily agree with everything, but they have been heard. And because of that they can follow and get behind me because they support the bigger success of the vision.

And it will create the type or culture and environment that generates creativity and trust among the group who is looking to you to move them to the next mountain top or through the next valley.

And best yet, you have a much greater chance of making a best decision because there is a safety in hearing many perspectives from those who are key to the future.

Lead by consensus, but first understand what it means and what it does not mean. Your people will be grateful you did. And they will follow.

I’d love to hear from you — please leave a reply below if you have any thoughts to add to the conversation.

If you know someone who would be helped by reading this, please share it using one of the social media links below. Thank you for doing this! 

And if you would like to begin receive a weekly email whenever future posts are made, you can subscribe here.  You may unsubscribe at any time.


Please Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s